Bathroom Renovations St Kilda Logo

DIY Bathroom Renovation: Weighing the Pros and Cons Before You Start

DIY bathroom renovation

They say, “A stitch in time saves nine” — and when it comes to a DIY Bathroom Renovation, those words couldn’t be more accurate. According to the 2023 Houzz & Home Australia Report, 59% of homeowners renovated their bathrooms to improve functionality and design, making it one of the most upgraded rooms in Australian homes. The appeal of doing it yourself can be strong in a vibrant suburb of Australia where old-world charm meets modern living.

But while a DIY renovation can be rewarding, it’s not without challenges. This guide will explore the pros and cons, highlight common pitfalls, and help you decide when to roll up your sleeves or call in the experts.

What is a DIY Bathroom Renovation?

A Do-it-yourself bathroom renovation means taking on all or most of the tasks involved in updating your bathroom—from planning and demolition to tiling, painting, and installing fixtures. It’s typically suitable for homeowners with handy skills, confidence, and a good grasp of timelines and budgets. Every project differs, from charming period homes to modern apartments. It can be rewarding, but it’s not for the faint-hearted.

The local vibe often favours individuality. Many homeowners opt for design styles that reflect personal taste, whether that’s a coastal-inspired look or chic urban minimalism. However, while planning a project, it’s essential to balance creativity with practicality, considering the age and structure of your property.

What is a DIY Bathroom Renovation

The Pros of Do-it-Yourself Renovation

  1. Cost-Saving Potential

Labour costs are a big part of any renovation budget. Doing much of the work yourself could save you thousands. This allows you to allocate funds to high-end fittings or luxury tiles instead in a place, where tardier rates can be steep. Use those savings for quality tapware from local showrooms or invest in natural stone features that elevate the entire space.

  1. Creative Freedom

These renovators control every detail—from selecting heritage-style fixtures for a Victorian terrace to bold modern designs for an apartment. Your bathroom can be exactly how you picture it without compromise. Experiment with feature walls, blend textures and add materials that appeal to the artistic community, like terrazzo or salvaged timber.

  1. Sense of Achievement

A real buzz comes from stepping back and knowing you created that space. Finishing a tiling job or installing a vanity alone can be incredibly satisfying. Hosting friends and family and hearing compliments on your handiwork is one of those intangible rewards that money can’t buy.

  1. Learning New Skills

Each project adds to your skill set. From plumbing basics to tiling patterns, the knowledge you gain can be useful for future projects around your home. These skills can also increase your confidence in tackling other small home improvement projects.

  1. Greater Control Over Budget and Timeline

You decide when to splurge and when to save. Plus, you set the renovation pace around your schedule, giving flexibility. If a busy week arises, you can pause and resume without worrying about Tradie’s availability.

  1. Customised Materials and Features

You can hand-pick environmentally friendly or locally sourced materials to support businesses. Shopping at neighbourhood hardware stores or local tile showrooms gives you access to unique finds and personalised service.

The Cons of Do-it-Yourself Renovation

  1. Time-Consuming

Renovations take time—often more than you expect. With busy lifestyles, juggling work, family, and a messy bathroom can quickly become stressful. These jobs frequently extend beyond planned timelines due to unexpected challenges, which can test your patience.

  1. Lack of Expertise

Tasks like waterproofing, plumbing, and electrical work require certified bathroom professionals. A small mistake can lead to problems later, like leaks or mould issues. Attempting complex tasks without experience could mean expensive corrections and potentially damaging your home.

  1. Costly Mistakes

Without experience, errors can happen — incorrectly installed tiles, misaligned fixtures, or plumbing mishaps. Rectifying these can cost more than hiring a professional in the first place. Small structural surprises can turn into major headaches in older properties.

  1. Compliance and Waterproofing Issues

The building codes are strict, especially regarding waterproofing and drainage. This work that doesn’t comply could lead to failed inspections or voided insurance. If not rectified, these issues may also impact future property sales.

  1. Stress and Overwhelm

Managing trades, sourcing materials, and solving unforeseen problems can become mentally exhausting. It’s easy to underestimate the emotional toll of this renovation.

  1. Limited Warranty and Insurance Coverage

Insurance policies may not cover mistakes made during this time, leaving you with added expenses. Professional installations typically come with warranties for peace of mind.

Common Do-it-Yourself Mistakes in Australia Homes

  • Underestimating Structural Challenges: Many properties are older homes with quirky layouts or hidden structural issues.
  • Ignoring Moisture Concerns: The coastal climate can make bathrooms more prone to dampness and mould.
  • Choosing Style Over Practicality: A freestanding tub looks stunning, but is it practical in a smaller Edwardian bathroom?
  • Skipping Permits: Homeowners sometimes forget to check if council permits are needed — especially for major plumbing alterations.
  • Poor Waterproofing Techniques: Water damage can ruin floors and walls without professional waterproofing.
  • Misjudging Electrical Work: Electrical upgrades are difficult, dangerous, and legally require licensed professionals.
  • Not Planning for Proper Ventilation: Good ventilation prevents mould in humid coastal areas.

How Local Property Types and Climate Influence DIY Decisions

  1. Heritage Homes: Extra care and special materials may be needed to preserve character while complying with regulations. Heritage overlays also restrict certain changes.
  2. Apartments: Noise restrictions, strata rules, and shared plumbing can limit what’s possible. For major works, you’ll need to coordinate with building management.
  3. Coastal Climate: High humidity demands careful attention to ventilation and waterproofing. Rust-resistant fixtures are advisable.
  4. Tight Spaces: Many older homes have smaller bathroom footprints, requiring smart design solutions. Compact vanities and corner showers may be necessary.

Planning a Successful Do-it-Yourself

  1. Start with a Clear Design Plan

Measure your space carefully and plan every detail. Whether you keep a vintage style or go contemporary, clarity helps avoid costly changes mid-project. Use 3D visualisation apps to bring your plan to life.

  1. Create a Detailed Budget

Factor in tools, materials, permit fees, and contingencies. For bulky items, remember to include the cost of delivery.

  1. List Tasks You Can Do Yourself vs. Tasks to Outsource

Tiling and painting may be manageable, but plumbing, electrical work, and waterproofing are generally not. Be realistic and avoid taking risks.

  1. Set Realistic Timelines

Allow extra time for unexpected delays. Schedule tasks around your work and family commitments.

  1. Consult Professionals for Advice

Design consultation from butlerBATHROOM+ can help you avoid expensive missteps. They can also recommend quality suppliers and help navigate local council approvals.

Is Do-it-Yourself Renovation Right for You? (A Checklist)

Ask yourself these questions before diving in:

  1. Do you have the time?

Bathroom renovations can disrupt daily life. Will you manage without a functional bathroom for weeks or months?

  1. Are you confident with tools?

Basic plumbing, tiling, and painting require skill. Mistakes can become costly.

  1. Have you done thorough research?

Planning is key. Know your local building codes and what jobs require licensed tradespeople.

  1. Do you know when to ask for help?

Even the most enthusiastic DIYers sometimes need to hire pros. If waterproofing or electrical work seems beyond your capabilities, consult professionals.

  1. Do you have a realistic budget?

It can save money, but unexpected costs (like tool hire or fixing mistakes) add up.

  1. Are you ready for setbacks?

Most renovations don’t go exactly as planned. Can you remain flexible?

  1. Is resale value important?

The shortcuts may be noticeable to future buyers or property inspectors.

When to Call in the Experts

While the renovation has charm, some projects are best left to professionals—especially in complex properties or when compliance is non-negotiable. If you’re searching and find yourself overwhelmed, professionals can step in with expertise and help you finish the job to the highest standards.

Benefits of Hiring Experts:

  • Certified workmanship with warranties
  • Access to premium materials at trade prices
  • Efficient timelines
  • Stress-free project management
  • Compliance with all local regulations
  • Expert design advice tailored to local homes

When to Call in the Experts

Ready to Renovate with Confidence? Get Expert Help!

A do-it-yourself renovation can be rewarding, creative, and cost-effective — but only with care and proper preparation. Before knocking down tiles or buying fixtures, weigh the pros and cons and consider your time, skills, and patience.

If you reach a point where it feels too much, remember that expert help is just around the corner. Contact butlerBATHROOM+ for guidance, peace of mind, and professional results that will make your St. Kilda bathroom shine.

Latest Articles

© 2025 Bathroom Renovations St. Kilda